yeah, I use to be all for david tennant but then after watching his seasons over so many times I was like.... maybe I should just watch Matt Smith's over again... and he and Amy have started to grow on me though I still think that david is better looking
I don't just like David because he's good looking (though that can be a contributing factor) Mainly I like his personality as the Doctor. Matt's version of the Doctor to me comes off as too much of a child in a way. Not that that's a bad thing. But then again it could be that I like David more than the others because I've known him as the Doctor the longest. (I haven't seen any of the previous doctors to the 9th)
IMO, the best actor to incarnate the Doctor sa of the character is still the Fourth, Tom Baker. Nobody can surpass him. But then agai, when I come to think of it, as a Whovian, I know that every appearance of the Doctor comes with a different personality, even though it's -in general- the same character. When you look at it closely, the ninth is as different to the Tenth as the Tenth is to Eleventh. i think that's a good way to deepen the Doctor's character, whether it be to the liking of everybody or not.
I've haven't known Dave for too long, mainly because everybody was crazy about him. But now that it has calmed down a little, I'm ready to watchhis seasons.